I rate this cd as 5 stars. Nothing but the best for the best!!


It's a Rosie Christmas!   October 29, 2000
Frankie B (Chicago, IL)
16 out of 20 found this review helpful

I REALLY enjoyed this CD. I did not buy the last, but will definitely now. I really enjoyed Donna Summer's new self- written tune, A Rosie Christmas. It's a Fab dance tune that happens to be about Christmas. I thought this song really stood out as one of the best on this CD along with the grand Linda Eder, Billy Gilman, and the hilaroius tune by the Dixie Chicks. This is truly a GREAT Christmas CD and it happens to benefit a children's charity. Get this CD NOW!! You don't know what you are missing.


White Trash Music   December 5, 2000
9 out of 27 found this review helpful

I'm sorry, the artists may be good, but anything Rosie is involved with seems to turn into garbage. She has poisoned this otherwise good endeavor with her crash commercialism. If you think you're doing something good, because some of the proceeds go to charity, remember that the bulk of it goes into Rosie's pockets...if you want to do something real this Christmas, help out the homeless directly, like I do every week. Do yourself a favor and get a good Christmas album, like the one by Rik Emmett. Don't forget how hypocritical Rosie is with her "charity". She is the one that said on national TV at the Million Mom March that she wants all guns banned from everyone...then turns around and hires a bodyguard for her family who carries a handgun. Sorry Rosie, I can't afford to hire an armed gunman, I spend too much time at the homeless shelter. Pass on this masquerade.


Oh No! It's Rosie O'Donnel!   December 17, 2000
Todd Gray (Holt, Michigan United States)
8 out of 21 found this review helpful

As we have all seen, Rosie is a bad mother. Her youngest child recently broke his leg due to neglect from Rosie being off in the other room counting her money. As we have also seen, and unfortunatly heard, she is an incredibly sub-par singer. If she has a thought on something she will not talk about it like the normal people in this world, she will "write" a song about it and have it go with the same music of one of her many favorite Broadway shows. This CD demonstrates how lazy Rosie is. There are only about half of these tracks that have Rosie on them, not that i am complaining. She also only selects the artists that we all have heard a thousand or more times on the local radio. Why be so superficial? why don't you work with some musical acts that are not as mainstream, and come up with some songs that are actually innovative, not just the same kind of music that we can all hear on the Top 40 countdown.


save your money   December 3, 2000
michael gilgenbach (south milwaukee, wi United States)
6 out of 8 found this review helpful

It was more enjoyable listening to the "barking dogs sing Christmas songs" then listening to her. It makes a great gag gift for your freinds though. Beware, they will want to retaliate!